Overcontributed to a 401(k)? What Happens and How to Fix It

If you’ve overcontributed to a 401(k), the IRS requires you to remove the excess — called an excess deferral — plus any earnings it generated, before April 15 of the following year. Miss that deadline and the same money gets taxed twice: once in the year you overcontributed and again when it’s eventually withdrawn. If you’re under 59½, a 10% early withdrawal penalty may also apply.

Overcontribution happens more often than most people realize — especially when changing jobs mid-year, receiving a large bonus, or contributing to two 401(k) plans at once. The good news: if you catch it before the deadline, the fix is straightforward.

This guide explains exactly what happens if you over contribute to a 401(k), how to fix it step by step, and how to prevent it from happening again.

Have you overcontributed to a 401(k) without realizing that you might be breaking some rules? You are not alone. Most overcontribution issues happen quietly. You do not notice them until tax season, when the correction becomes urgent and stressful. But don’t worry! This article is here to explain to you what to do if you overcontribute to a 401(k).

What is meant by Overcontribution to a 401(k)?

You overcontribute to 401(k) when the total amount you personally put into all 401(k) plans during the year exceeds the IRS employee contribution limit. This rule applies even if each employer followed the rules individually. The IRS looks at the combined total under your name and Social Security number.

That makes the responsibility yours, not your employer’s. The excess does not disappear. It must be corrected, or it creates tax problems.

What are the Most Common Reasons for a 401(k) Overcontribution?

An overcontribution to 401k rarely comes from trying to save too much. It usually comes from changes during the year. Some of the most common factors are as follows:

• Mid-Year Job Change

  IRS limits apply to your total contributions across all employers in a calendar year. Payroll systems do not talk to each other. When you change jobs, receive a raise, or earn a bonus, those systems keep contributing unless you intervene.

• Having More Than One 401(k) Plan

  Contributing to two plans at once increases the risk. No automatic system combines the totals for you. Tracking becomes your responsibility.

• Errors of Payroll or Administrator

  Mistakes happen. Sometimes payroll systems miscalculate limits or fail to stop contributions on time. These errors often surface late in the year.

• Variable Compensation or Bonuses

  Bonuses can push you over the edge. If contributions are percentage-based, a large payout can suddenly create an excess.

What Happens If You Overcontribute to Two 401(k) Plans in the Same Year?

Changing jobs mid-year is the single most common trigger for a 401(k) overcontribution — and it catches a lot of people off guard. Here is why: the $24,500 employee contribution limit for 2026 is a personal annual limit tied to your Social Security number, not a per-employer limit. Your payroll system at Job A and your payroll system at Job B have no way of talking to each other. Both will keep deducting contributions from your paychecks, potentially pushing your combined total past the IRS cap.

Real-world example — 2026
You left Job A in July 2026, having contributed $15,000 to their 401(k) plan. You joined Job B in August and, not thinking to tell their payroll department, set your contributions at 10% of a $120,000 salary. By December 31, Job B’s plan has received another $12,000 from you.

Your combined total: $27,000.
The 2026 IRS employee limit: $24,500.
Your excess deferral: $2,500 — and neither employer’s plan technically did anything wrong.

The IRS looks at your combined total under your SSN, which means the correction responsibility falls entirely on you.

Which plan do you pull the excess from?

You get to choose. If both plans allow corrective distributions, request the $2,500 from whichever plan makes more sense — typically the plan with lower investment returns on the excess, or the plan that is easier to access for administrative purposes. Notify the plan administrator of that plan in writing before March 1 and request the corrective distribution before April 15.

What if you contributed to a 401(k) and a 403(b) in the same year?

The same combined limit applies. The $24,500 employee elective deferral limit is aggregated across 401(k), 403(b), and SARSEP plans. A 457(b) plan, however, has its own separate limit — so if your second plan is a 457(b), the rules work differently. When in doubt, consult a retirement plan specialist before requesting any distribution.

What are the Current Contribution Limits for 401(k)?

IRS limits change periodically, so checking them each year matters. The limits for the year 2025-26 are as follows:

• Employee contribution limit: $24,500
• Catch-up contribution (age 50+): $8,000
• Higher catch-up Contribution (age 60 to 63): $11,250

These limits apply only to employee contributions. They include money contributed across all employers combined.

Does your employer’s matching contribution count toward these limits?

No — and this is one of the most common points of confusion. Your employer’s matching contributions do not count toward the $24,500 employee elective deferral limit. Only the money that comes out of your own paycheck counts against that cap. Employer contributions count toward a separate, higher limit: the total annual additions limit, which is $72,000 in 2026 (or up to $83,250 including catch-up contributions).

This means that even if your employer matches 5% of your salary, you are not at risk of an employee overcontribution from the match itself. Overcontribution is always caused by your own elective deferrals exceeding the IRS employee limit — not by employer generosity.

How Can You Tell If You’ve Overcontributed to a 401(k)?

If you suspect an issue, a few simple checks can confirm if you have overcontributed to a 401(k). Catching the issue early makes correction much easier.

• Review Plan StatementsLook at year-to-date totals on each provider’s portal.
• Check Your W-2 FormsBox 12 codes D and AA list retirement contributions.
• Watch for TriggersJob changes, raises, and bonuses often cause accidental excess.
• Compare Totals to IRS LimitsAdd everything together and compare it to the cap.

What Should You Do If You Overcontribute to a 401(k)?

When you are searching for the answer to what to do if you’ve overcontributed to a 401(k), you must know that timing matters more than anything else. Follow this process ASAP:

The Correction Timeline at a Glance

Time is the most important factor when fixing a 401(k) excess deferral. Here is the complete sequence from discovery to resolution:

1. Discover the excess — Review year-to-date contribution totals across all 401(k) plans, ideally by December 31 but no later than early January.
2. Notify your plan administrator in writing — Do this by March 1. Tell them the exact dollar amount of the excess and the year it occurred. Get a written confirmation back.
3. Corrective distribution is processed — The plan removes the excess deferral plus allocable earnings. This must be completed by April 15.
4. You receive Form 1099-R — The plan issues a Form 1099-R by January 31 of the year following the distribution. The excess deferral amount is reported as taxable income for the year it was contributed.
5. File or amend your tax return — Report the corrective distribution on your tax return for the year of the excess. If you already filed before receiving the 1099-R, you may need to file an amended return (Form 1040-X).

• December 31 — deadline for contributions to count in current tax year
• March 1 — deadline to notify your plan administrator of excess
• April 15 — deadline to complete the corrective distribution (same date as tax filing deadline — not a coincidence)
• January 31 (following year) — date by which you should receive Form 1099-R

1. Notify Your Employer or Plan Administrator

   Reach out to your employer or plan provider as soon as you notice the excess. They can explain the corrective process and paperwork.

2. Request a Corrective Distribution

   The excess amount and any related earnings must be removed from the plan.

3. Pay Attention to Deadlines

   Corrections must happen before the IRS deadline to avoid penalties and repeat taxation.

4. Prepare for Tax Reporting

   You receive a Form 1099-R. Your employer may also issue a corrected W-2.

How Does an Excess 401(k) Contribution Affect Your Taxes?

An uncorrected excess creates double taxation. The contribution is taxed in the year it was made and taxed again when withdrawn later. If the correction is late and you are under 59½, a 10% early withdrawal penalty may also apply. This is the real cost of ignoring what happens if you overcontribute to your 401(k).

What are the Key Deadlines for Rectifications If You Overcontributed to a 401(k)?

Deadlines are strict.

• March 1For notifying excess contribution to your employer or plan administrator.
• April 15For completing the corrective distribution of the excess amount and earnings.

Missing these dates can have serious implications, such as double taxation, paperwork, and penalties.

What Happens If You Miss the April 15 Deadline to Fix a 401(k) Overcontribution?

Missing the April 15 deadline is the most expensive outcome of a 401(k) overcontribution. Here is exactly what happens when the correction does not happen on time:

1. Double taxation. The excess deferral is included in your taxable income for the year it was contributed. Then, when it is eventually distributed from the plan — even years later — it is taxed as ordinary income a second time. You will have paid tax on the same money twice with no way to recover the overpayment.
2. 10% early distribution penalty. If you are under age 59½ when the late distribution is finally made, the IRS applies an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty on the full amount under IRC Section 72(t). A timely corrective distribution by April 15 is explicitly exempt from this penalty — a late one is not.
3. Potential plan disqualification risk. If excess deferrals remain in the plan uncorrected, the employer’s entire 401(k) plan could face disqualification under IRC Section 401(a)(30). This would have sweeping tax consequences for all participants. Most employers work quickly to avoid this, but the underlying responsibility still began with your excess contribution.

Dollar example — late correction
You overcontributed $2,500 in 2025. You miss the April 15, 2026 deadline. In November 2026, the plan finally distributes the $2,500 plus $200 in earnings ($2,700 total). You are 45 years old.

• Tax owed in 2025 on the $2,500 excess: ~$625 (at 25% bracket)
• Tax owed again in 2026 on the $2,700 distribution: ~$675
• 10% early withdrawal penalty on $2,700: $270
• Total extra tax cost of missing the deadline: approximately $945 more than if corrected on time.

Note: This is a simplified illustration. Your actual tax cost depends on your bracket, state taxes, and whether the plan withholds 20%. Consult a tax professional for your specific situation.

What if you have already missed the April 15 deadline?

You can still correct the error, but you must do so through the IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS). The correction method under EPCRS still requires distributing the excess plus earnings and reporting the amounts on Form 1099-R, but it does not eliminate the double taxation or the early withdrawal penalty. The sooner you act, the better — delaying further only compounds the problem.

How Can You Avoid Overcontributing to a 401(k) in the Future?

Preventing an overcontribution to 401(k) does not require complex math or constant monitoring. It comes down to awareness, timing, and a few small habit changes. Here is how to stay ahead of it.

• Adjust Contributions After Raises

  If your contributions are set as a percentage of pay, a raise automatically increases how much goes into your 401(k). It can quietly push you past the IRS limit later in the year. Switching to a fixed dollar amount gives you control. You decide exactly how much goes in each paycheck, regardless of salary changes.

  This makes it easier to stay within annual limits, especially after promotions or mid-year raises.

• Communicate During Job Changes

  When you change jobs mid-year, your new employer has no way to see how much you already contributed to your 401(k). This is one of the most common reasons people overcontribute to 401k. Sharing your year-to-date contribution total early allows payroll or the plan administrator to adjust your contribution rate.

• Track Contributions Regularly

  Checking your total contributions a few times a year makes a big difference. This is especially important if you change jobs, receive bonuses, or get paid irregularly. Adding up contributions across all employers helps you catch problems early. It also gives you time to reduce or pause contributions before an excess builds up.

• Use Plan Controls

  Many 401(k) plans allow you to set a maximum dollar limit for the year. Once that limit is reached, contributions stop automatically. If your plan offers this feature, use it. It acts as a safety net and removes the risk of accidental overcontribution caused by payroll changes or variable income.

• Review Pay Stubs Often

  Your pay stub shows how much you contributed and your year-to-date total. A glance can reveal issues before they grow. Catching a small error early is much easier than fixing an excess contribution months later.

Where to Put Your Extra Savings After Correcting a 401(k) Overcontribution

Once the excess is returned to you, that money is back in your hands — and you will likely want to put it to work rather than let it sit in a checking account. Depending on your situation, several tax-advantaged options may be available to you.

• Roth IRA. If you have earned income and your income falls within the IRS limits, you can contribute up to $7,000 in 2026 (or $8,000 if you are 50 or older) to a Roth IRA. Contributions are made with after-tax dollars, but qualified withdrawals in retirement are completely tax-free. Because the corrective distribution you received has already been taxed, routing it into a Roth IRA makes efficient use of the money. Learn more about Roth IRA contribution rules and limits.
• Traditional IRA. If you prefer a current-year tax deduction, a Traditional IRA may allow you to deduct your contribution depending on your income and whether you are covered by a workplace plan. The annual limit is the same as the Roth IRA. See how a Traditional IRA compares to a Roth IRA.
• Health Savings Account (HSA). If you are enrolled in a High Deductible Health Plan, an HSA offers a triple tax advantage: contributions are tax-deductible, growth is tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. The 2026 HSA contribution limit is $4,300 for individuals and $8,550 for families.
• Self-Directed IRA or 401(k). For investors who want more control over where their retirement savings go — including real estate, private equity, or other alternative assets — a Self-Directed IRA or Solo 401(k) may be worth exploring. Explore Self-Directed IRA options.

None of these options require you to make a decision immediately after the corrective distribution. But having a plan in place before April 15 means your money is working for you rather than sitting idle. A retirement specialist can help you identify which vehicle fits your current income, tax situation, and long-term goals.

Is Overcontribution to a 401(k) Ever a Good Thing?

It may feel productive if you’ve overcontributed to 401k, but the tax impact usually outweighs any benefit. Staying within limits keeps your savings clean, compliant, and growing without friction. If you need help fixing an issue or planning contributions more effectively, expert guidance can save time and money.

Reviewed for accuracy: March 2026. IRS contribution limits and penalty rules updated to reflect 2025 and 2026 figures. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified tax professional or retirement specialist regarding your individual situation.

Disclaimer: The information on this page is provided for general educational purposes and reflects IRS rules as of March 2026. Tax rules, contribution limits, and penalty amounts are subject to change. Nothing on this page constitutes tax, legal, or financial advice. Individuals with excess 401(k) deferrals should consult a licensed tax professional or retirement plan specialist before taking any corrective action.

FAQs