Table of Contents
Save thousands each year, and gain control of what's yours.
Join our newsletter
to get trending content!
Key Takeaways
- A Roth in-plan conversion allows you to move money from the pre-tax side of your employer retirement plan into the Roth portion, paying taxes now in exchange for tax-free withdrawals later. It keeps the money inside the plan and does not require opening a Roth IRA.
- The main benefit of an in-plan Roth conversion is long-term tax flexibility. It can help create tax-free retirement income, diversify tax exposure, and reduce reliance on taxable withdrawals later in life.
- In-plan Roth conversion taxes are due in the year of conversion, and the amount converted is added to your ordinary income. Proper timing and having cash available to pay the tax are critical to making the strategy work.
- A Roth in-plan conversion is permanent and governed by specific in-plan Roth conversion rules, including five-year holding requirements and plan-specific limits. Gradual, well-planned conversions often provide better results than converting a large balance all at once.
If you’ve been looking for ways to get more tax flexibility in retirement, you may have come across the term Roth in plan conversion. At first glance, it sounds complicated. In reality, it’s a strategy that can be powerful in the right situation and unnecessary in others.
This article breaks it down clearly. No heavy jargon. No sales pitch. Just a practical explanation of what a Roth in-plan conversion is, how it works, and when it may (or may not) be worth considering.
What is a Roth In-Plan Conversion?
Roth in-plan conversion is a way to move money inside your employer-sponsored retirement plan from traditional (pre-tax) to Roth (after-tax). You pay income tax on the converted amount in the year of the conversion, but future qualified withdrawals can be tax-free.
This approach helps build tax-free retirement income without opening a separate Roth IRA. However, the conversion is permanent and increases your taxable income for that year, so timing and tax planning matter.
This strategy is also known as:
- In-Plan Roth Conversion
- In-Plan Roth Rollover
- 401(k) In-Plan Roth Conversion
Curious how this differs from a standard Roth IRA?
While an In-Plan Conversion happens inside your employer’s path, a Roth IRA offers different flexibility. Check out our deep dive:
What is Roth IRA? Benefits, Key Features and Eligibility Criteria
How Does an In-Plan Roth Conversion Work?
An in-plan Roth conversion starts with money already inside your retirement plan. This could be:
- Pre-tax 401(k) contributions
Before you decide how much to contribute pre-tax, make sure you know the latest IRS caps.
See the 401(k) Contribution Limits and Deadlines for 2025 and 2026 here.
- Employer matching contributions
- After-tax contributions (if your plan allows them)
Once you request the conversion:
- The selected amount is moved from traditional to Roth inside the plan.
- That amount is added to your taxable income for the year.
- The converted funds grow inside the Roth portion of your plan.
You don’t receive the money personally. There is no withdrawal. It’s simply reclassified within the plan.
What are the Different Types of Retirement Plans That Allow Roth In-Plan Conversions?
Not all employer plans allow in-plan Roth conversion strategies. Your plan document must specifically permit it.
| Plan Type | Roth In-Plan Conversion Allowed? |
|---|---|
| 401(k) | Yes (if plan allows) |
| Solo 401(k) | Yes |
| 403(b) | Yes |
| Government 457(b) | Yes |
| Traditional IRA | No (outside employer plan) |
Before making any decisions, confirm what your specific plan allows.
Why Consider a Roth In-Plan Conversion?
A Roth in plan conversion is not about chasing tax tricks. It is about control. Control over future in-plan Roth conversion taxes, income timing, and how flexible your retirement money can be later in life. Here are the main reasons investors choose this strategy.
-
Tax-Free Retirement Income
One of the biggest advantages of a Roth in-plan conversion is the potential for tax-free income later. Once converted, qualified withdrawals from the Roth portion are not taxed. This can be especially valuable if tax rates rise in the future or if your income is higher in retirement than expected.
Having tax-free income gives you peace of mind. You know exactly how much money you can spend without worrying about the IRS taking a portion.
-
Tax Diversification
Relying on only pre-tax retirement accounts can limit your options. A mix of traditional and Roth funds gives flexibility. With In-plan Roth conversion strategies, you can choose which bucket to pull from each year.
This helps manage taxes year by year. It also allows you to avoid pushing yourself into a higher tax bracket during retirement.
-
Capitalize on Lower Income Years
There are seasons in life when income dips. This could be due to a job change, business slowdown, or partial retirement. These years can be ideal for a Roth in-plan conversion. Converting while your tax rate is lower reduces the overall tax cost. Over time, this can lead to significant savings.
-
Avoid Early Withdrawal Penalties
A common misconception is that converting triggers penalties. It does not. An In-plan Roth conversion keeps your money inside the retirement plan. As long as the funds stay in the plan, early withdrawal penalties do not apply. This makes it a safer option than taking distributions.
-
No Income Limits
Unlike Roth IRA contributions, there is no income limit for in-plan Roth conversion. If your employer plan allows it, you can convert regardless of how much you earn. This makes it especially useful for high-income earners who want Roth exposure.
-
Estate Planning Benefits
Roth assets can be easier on heirs. Beneficiaries often receive distributions that are tax-free. This makes a Roth in-plan conversion attractive if you are thinking beyond your own retirement and planning for legacy goals.
Tax Implications of a Roth In-Plan Conversion
Understanding the in-plan Roth conversion taxes is critical before moving forward. The converted amount is treated as ordinary income in the year of conversion. This may push you into a higher tax bracket or affect tax credits and deductions.
Many plans do not withhold taxes automatically, so you may need to pay them out of pocket. Planning ahead helps prevent surprises at tax time.
In-Plan Roth Conversion Rules
There are specific in-plan Roth conversion rules investors should understand. Once you convert, the decision cannot be reversed. Roth funds are also subject to five-year holding rules before withdrawals can be completely tax-free. In addition, employer plans may limit how often or how much you can convert.
While there is no IRS-imposed in-plan Roth conversion limit, your plan administrator may impose restrictions.
When Would an In-Plan Roth Conversion Be Helpful?
A Roth in-plan conversion works best when timing and personal circumstances align. Below are situations where this strategy often makes sense.
-
When You are Young and in a Lower Tax Bracket
If you are young, you usually earn less early in your career. Paying taxes now at a lower rate through an in-plan can be far cheaper than paying higher taxes decades later. The longer time horizon also allows for more tax-free growth.
-
When There are Significant Medical Expenses
Large medical expenses may create deductions that lower taxable income. This can offset in-plan Roth conversion taxes, making the conversion more affordable in that year. In these cases, the tax impact may be much smaller than expected.
-
If You are a High Net Worth Individual
In case you are a high-net-worth investor, you might often face large required minimum distributions later. A Roth in-plan conversion can help reduce future taxable income by shifting part of the portfolio into Roth status early. This also helps with long-term tax planning and estate efficiency.
-
When Moving to a Higher-Tax State
If you plan to relocate to a state with higher income taxes, converting before the move may lower lifetime tax costs. A Roth in-plan conversion completed earlier can lock in taxes at lower state rates.
-
After a Market Downturn
When account values drop, the taxable amount of a Roth in-plan conversion is lower. This allows you to convert more shares for less tax, setting up stronger tax-free growth during a market recovery.
When Would a Roth In-Plan Conversion Not Be Helpful?
While an in-plan conversion can be powerful, it is not always the right move. You must avoid it in the following circumstances:
-
When There is No Extra Cash to Pay the Tax
If you cannot pay the conversion tax from outside funds, the strategy may backfire. Using plan assets to cover in-plan Roth conversion taxes reduces long-term growth and may trigger penalties. Cash flow matters just as much as tax planning.
-
When You are Close to Retirement and in a High Tax Bracket
If retirement is only a few years away, there may not be enough time for tax-free growth to offset the upfront tax cost. In these cases, keeping funds in traditional accounts may be more practical. This is especially true for high earners nearing retirement.
Common Roth In-Plan Conversion Mistakes to Avoid
Even well-intentioned investors can make mistakes with an in-plan conversion. Check out the missteps that often reduce this strategy’s benefits.
-
Assuming IRA Rules Apply to Employer Plans
Employer plans follow different sourcing and pro-rata rules. An in-plan Roth conversion does not work the same way as an IRA conversion.
-
Paying Conversion Taxes From Plan Assets
This reduces your retirement balance and may create penalties. Taxes should ideally be paid from savings outside the plan.
-
Converting Too Much in One Year
Large conversions can push you into higher tax brackets. Spreading conversions over several years often leads to better results.
-
Ignoring the Five-Year Rules
Roth funds must meet holding requirements before withdrawals are tax-free. Missing this detail can lead to unexpected taxes.
-
Skipping Professional Guidance
An in-plan conversion affects income taxes, Medicare premiums, and estate planning. Without proper modeling, small mistakes can become expensive.
A Roth in-plan conversion is not an all-or-nothing decision. In many cases, gradual conversions over multiple years provide better tax efficiency and flexibility. If you are considering an in-plan conversion and want help evaluating whether it fits your retirement strategy, contact Self Directed Retirement Plans LLC. Proper structure and timing matter.
Every financial situation is unique, and timing is everything.
If you’re unsure how a conversion will impact your tax bill this year, we’re here to help.
FAQs
Does an In-plan Roth conversion count as income?
Yes. The converted amount is included in your taxable income for that year. This can affect tax brackets and other income-based calculations.
Are there income limits for Roth in-plan conversions?
No. In-plan conversion eligibility is based on employer plan rules, not income level.
Can I do a Roth in-plan conversion every year?
Yes, if your plan allows it. Some plans allow partial or recurring conversions.
Is a Roth in-plan conversion reversible?
No, it’s not! Once the conversion is completed, it cannot be undone.
Should I convert my entire 401(k) at once?
Ideally, you should not convert your entire 401(K) at once. Large conversions can create unnecessary tax pressure. Phased conversions often work better.
How does an in-plan Roth conversion affect RMDs?
Roth 401(k) balances are still subject to RMDs unless rolled into a Roth IRA. Many investors eventually roll Roth funds into a Roth IRA to avoid plan-based RMDs.
Is this the same as a mega backdoor Roth?
No. A mega backdoor Roth uses after-tax contributions plus a conversion strategy. The in-plan Roth conversion is one component of that broader approach.
Can I do both Roth contributions and Roth in-plan conversions in the same year?
Yes. If your plan allows both, you can contribute new Roth funds and convert existing balances in the same year.
What happens if I leave my job after a conversion?
You can usually roll your Roth 401(k) balance into a Roth IRA or another employer plan. The five-year clocks continue, so documentation is important.
Should I get professional advice before converting?
Yes. Conversions affect taxes, Medicare premiums, and estate planning. Professional modeling is strongly recommended for larger conversions.
